Agate vs Flint for flintlock ?




Attention Alaska Artisans and Product Manufacturers!

If you are an Alaska-based Artisan, Crafstman, Author, or Product Manufacturer, or any local business offering products available for sale, we welcome you to add a listing to the AOS Directory. Basic listings are free, and include a summary of your business, physical address, 1 photo and an email address.
Paid listings are being offered through a special promotion: $150/year includes a Featured Directory listing, a link to your website, phone number, email address and a forum welcome announcement linked to your directory listing. We look forward to presenting Alaska products to our audience! Please send an email message to if you would like to submit your listing or receive additional information.
Click arrow in top right corner for next announcement.
See more
See less
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Agate vs Flint for flintlock ?

    Was looking at the Midway web site and noted that they offer an agate "flint" in addition to the regular flints. They claim that the agate lasts longer and produces twice the strikes. Any truth to the advertising? Anybody have any experience with agate? good? bad? indifferent?

  • #2
    I have had the best luck with English flints. The French amber take second place, and the agate were pretty worthless. The ones I purchased several years back sparked all right initially, but they became dull really fast and I couldn't resharpen the edges where they didn't just dull back down after a couple shots. All I use anymore are English flints. Maybe someone else had better luck than I did with the agate type.


    • #3

      Years ago I tried the discount flints of the time: choate (sp?) and had pretty bad luck.

      I picked up a bag of 100 cheap arrowheads of roughly the same stuff. You know the ones that aren't good for much but selling to tourist. Several were broken and on a hare I put one in a little flintlock pistol that I didn't have a small enough flint for. Sparks everywhere! This stuff could have set off the firelocks next to yours too. You just never know about these odd rocks but English flints seem to be the most reliable overall and they aren't that expensive.


      Footer Adsense