Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Not Impressed With AK Outdoor TV Show

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Not Impressed With AK Outdoor TV Show

    Well I just watched the show tonight and I have had enough of the praise they have been receiving here on ODD. I'm going to speak out with the negative view. I'm going to try and keep this post civil so as not to get deleted, but there is always two sides to a discussion. I think that they have shown several shows that they refuse to reveal the destination. I understand the reasoning behind this but i don't agree with showing a bunch of buffed out guys doing a hunt that the average Alaskan couldn't do or afford in the first place, and then keep the destination a secret.

    I would much rather watch a show like Larry's, Audrey's and Smokey Joe's any day. I apologize to those that don't agree, but lets hear your rebuttal. Bring it on.
    Last edited by Brian M; 01-24-2009, 22:50. Reason: negative comments about individuals deleted

  • #2
    I Love North to Alaska, I think its a great show

    Comment


    • #3
      Didn't watch today's show, but have seen pieces of a few others. I guess I'd say it's better than most of what's on the Outdoor Channel.
      Don't know the fellow you are insulting & calling unethical. And I'm sure you are right, there probably are 2 sides to the discussion.
      As for revealing destinations on public land, I don't expect any hunting show to do that.
      Vance in AK.

      Matthew 6:33
      "But seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things shall be added to you."

      Comment


      • #4
        Better alaskans

        then guy's from from Ohio (miami)have done a couple shows for larry and even saved his A-- for another guide,only to get slapped in the face in my own back yard with some guide comeing during the peak of fishing from california.did only one other hunt on film to were we did not restage any part of it like with larry, and was happy,tim and his crew are welcomed by the campfire here.
        www.akbushguides.com

        Comment


        • #5
          win some loose some....
          some will be happy some won't....bottom line becomes favoring the lesser of the two evils.
          I haven't seen the show and probably won't, i have a hard time watching alaska hunting of fishing on tv with out crituiqing (sp) everything they do. as for not showing where they are...DUH.
          I think its fine that you don't favor the show and i think its fine you've expressed your views in here, thats what we all do. Another viewpoint on any subject i belive is always necessary.
          if you want to see some more good stuff check out www.greatlandproductions.com for some awesome alaska hunting videos, they don't tell you where they are though....lol
          Www.blackriverhunting.com
          Master guide 212

          Comment


          • #6
            I think they are pretty good, but....

            I would have to watch the shows again to remember what I had seen. But it seems like there are a few episodes where they broke the law. Probably a lot of people do the same thing. The problem is to broadcast it for the general puplic. Granted everyone should know the laws though. One is king fishing. I know somewhere in the regs it says you cannot remove a king salmon from the water that is not gonna be kept. Even to remove the hook they are to be kept in the water. Might be only for a certain area, have not looked it up. Another is I belive they were hunting with bow. The guy had the lighted knocks=illegal from what I get from the law, it is artificial light. Seems like some other stuff I have seen, just can't remember.

            As far as locations. I am surprised at the info they have given out! Even shown the GPS screen while hunting on the boat! Otherwise a pretty good show. I could be wrong about the things I think are illegal too.....

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by BRWNBR View Post
              if you want to see some more good stuff check out www.greatlandproductions.com for some awesome alaska hunting videos, they don't tell you where they are though....lol
              Jake, I agree on the Greatlands Production stuff. Top shelf, & the wife even enjoys them. Just picked up "Big into Bears" at Wiggy's when I was in ANC, & while it was good, I didn't enjoy it as much as the others I have. It was more of a "whackem-n-stackem" kind a video than the others.

              Akrstabout, I may be wrong but I think the illuminocks are OK. They aren't producing light until they are shot & the light doesn't aid in the shooting of the game. Kind of like using a flashlight to bloodtrail a wounded animal.
              Vance in AK.

              Matthew 6:33
              "But seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things shall be added to you."

              Comment


              • #8
                At least they are trying.

                I watched todays show, saw it before. I give them props for producing & airing a show. Takes a lot! U can not please everyone that is for certain.
                The two things that stuck out for me in this show was crossing a stream in glacier socks you could have hopped over & the fact they said two guides in the area were also hunting in that area. They reported that one had taken 7 legal rams out of that area in one year??? Nice to know it is an "UNLIMTED" resource for that particular guide to exploit. There any self control or did someone fall asleep in Biology class. :mad:

                Comment


                • #9
                  Makes ya go, huh?

                  This may be shooting from the hip a bit, and I don't voice my opinion too often, as you'll notice by the post count, but that 7 rams, by one guide got me thinking. I have knowledge of one outfit, taking 15 rams out of 16 hunters this past season. Granted planes are a great thing, but I gotta think logistically speaking, an outfit that size would wanna keep things pretty close.

                  How many drainages are being completely wiped out? And here I am, just a lowly resident, crossing my fingers for a permit in a week or two...
                  J

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    a little off the mark

                    Did they get their sheep? I would guess not, otherwise they wouldn't be complaining about another guide on a t.v. show. While I understand your point it seems hyprocitical because if they would have got their sheep nothing would have been said, or its a personal thing, neither of which should be on a professional show.
                    I did see some of the show where one went after the black bear with a bow & it ended up being shot by one of the two guys down below. Maybe it was just the camera angle but seems pretty unsafe to have some one crawling down from above trying to get within bow range & he said he was almost there when the other guy shot it. I sure wouldn't want someone shooting at an animal that I am with in 50 yds of from below me. Not real safe or professional again.
                    So while I give them credit for trying the show kind of misses. They obviously have the financial resources to do these hunts & possibly have a few sponsors but the end product isn't what I would expect.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      They do a good job

                      I saw todays show and I think they do a great job. I have viewed 2-3 of the shows now and I like them. THE MUSIC PORTION OF THE SHOW IS THE WORST AND WISH THEY WOULD TUNE THAT DOWN. Sounds like a Snowmachine video. Anyway, I look forward to seeing some more of the shows.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by Sockeye Salm View Post

                        Bring it on.

                        Watch Oprah instead. All her book reviews include all the info you need to locate and buy the books yourself and you don't have to be "buff" or wealthy to read self help books


                        Are you seriously complaining that you have another Alaska outdoor show to watch?
                        The two loudest sounds known to man: a gun that goes bang when it is supposed to go click and a gun that goes click when it is supposed to go bang.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Well I just watched the show tonight and I have had enough of the praise they have been receiving here on ODD. I'm going to speak out with the negative view. I'm going to try and keep this post civil so as not to get deleted, but there is always two sides to a discussion. I think that they have shown several shows that they refuse to reveal the destination. I understand the reasoning behind this but i don't agree with showing a bunch of buffed out guys doing a hunt that the average Alaskan couldn't do or afford in the first place, and then keep the destination a secret.

                          I would much rather watch a show like Larry's, Audrey's and Smokey Joe's any day. I apologize to those that don't agree, but lets hear your rebuttal. Bring it on.


                          I appreciate all feedback pro or con for the show and will do my best to address these comments - the original post was edited so I can only reply to what I see here now.

                          Fact; not everyone here is going to like the show. Period.

                          I would be silly mad to think in any one given day of my 27+ years of producing TV that I would please everyone. Not happening. Alaska Outdoors TV (AKODTV) was designed (massaged over a 4 year period) to appeal to broad based outdoor group of enthusiasts; men and women both residents and non-residents alike. AKODTV is entertainment valued-outdoor recreation program meaning its purpose is to entertain and encourage people to become involved with Alaskaís outdoor recreational opportunities. This is not a how to Ė where to or tell all instructional video for hunting and fishing Alaska.

                          Sockeye Salm (John),

                          I think weíd both agree making public on television your special hunting area would not please you. Itís a professional courtesy to those hunting and to avoid impact to the area. Steelhead, Shrimp pot placement or over sensitive outdoor areas same rule applies. Exact locations for certain adventures in some episodes are not made public for these obvious reasons.

                          Buffed out, I think possibly your reference is to the physical shape Dall sheep hunting requires you to be in which may not be a realistic goal for anyone less than dedicated to physically preparing for this type of hunt. Moose, caribou and Bear hunting can be just as physically demanding especially packing out as I'm sure you know.

                          You statement is incorrect in reasoning this hunts cost is not within reach of the average Alaskan hunter and I believe you may even suggest Csonkaís adventures are more affordable. Alaska has the highest number of pilots per capita of any state -- six times the number in the Lower 48. Thatís a lot of average Alaskan hunters that own planes. Total costs for that sheep hunt - Under $1,000 for plane fuel and food for three not counting hunting clothes, backpacks or other needed personal assets. If you canít afford that than you certainly canít afford to stay at any number of the 100ís of lodges Larry has visited and based his adventures out of over the years.

                          Alaska Outdoors Television was created by Alaskans for Alaskans to profile and showcase self-guided adventures and the Alaskan lifestyle. Itís not produced by an out-of-state million dollar production company nor is it designed to be slick and over acted. This first season we knew there would be kinks to work out and that not everything may go as plan but we decided to take a chance on something new for outdoor programming.

                          As always I appreciate the comments regardless what side of the fence you sit on. Know that its not often viewers have direct access with the shows producer so I think this can be a great opportunity to create a product many can enjoy.

                          Here are a few FACTS that may help out;

                          We refer to law enforcement agencies for regulation guidance and not the internet.

                          One illegal ram was taken by one of the two guiding outfits that had harvested 7 rams in that area which is why we made mention of the guiding pressure there. This was direct information from a Wild Life Trooper on scene that confiscated the ram and ticketed both the guide and out-of-state hunter. Weíre not opposed to professional ethical guiding by any means and in fact support it. Many of our friends are professional guides.

                          AKODTV produces self-guided programs. This doesnít mean we donít on occasion pay for accommodations or borrow a boat or bum a ride but for the most part these adventures are paid for out of our pockets.

                          We donít pay professional guides to guide us.

                          We DONíT barter w/lodges for free lodging or guiding services in trade for promotion in this TV series. This presents the average viewer with an adventure they can participate in and not a free $5,000 adventure package we just happened to get for free.

                          We do use some anglers/hunters in the show that do or have worked as professional guides. Iím sure some of you may have friends working as a professional guide that you also hunt/fish with.

                          Actions or judgment calls can be construed as mistakes depending on your take or who you ask. These are self-guided adventures with groups of enthusiasts that have either fished or hunted together for years and feel comfortable in groups. We take every precaution for safety with the goal of projecting a safe adventure environment. That said Iím always learning.

                          Black Bear episode - the bow hunter distance facts were overstated and misspoken. Unfortunate mistake exaggarated through editing. This was my first episode and a mistake on my part that I take full responsibility for as producer and you can be assured it wonít happen again.

                          Music Ė personal taste will always vary in this medium. Itís really a no win situation.

                          Best,
                          Tim
                          Alaska Outdoors Television ~ Outdoor Channel

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Impressed

                            I am always impressed with folks that have a vision and go for it.
                            My teenage son and I watched It kept me captivated and very interested,, yes I turned down the music, and he said,.
                            " Hey what you doing?".. I know that lots of personel taste goes into this kind of Art,, so I was not offended, just not interested in certain types of music,,, so it is ....a matter of taste..
                            As I watch different outdoor shows on all the different networks, I find that some fit my personality better than others..
                            One outfit that has always impressed me above all the other shows out there, is the Eastman shows. I used to watch the old mans work 40 years ago, and loved it, even back then it was much more professionally done than most shows now days.. Then what is cool is that Now days The Eastman boys are doing it, and doing a great job too.. they are polite, not showing flexing muscles, No crazy speed up video or weird angles, etc... and very down to earth. They are good about explaining stuff without creative camera work, like all the crazy movements etc that many shows think are the rage.... very stable shooting.. My son enjoys their shows too, and My wife likes them also.. Its only one a few that she will watch with me.. That says alot when you can get an old man like me, a young teenager and a Mom to sit and enjoy a hunting or outdoor show...
                            she said to me.. that she can't stand it when some dude shoots an animal and then does the " Thank you lord JESUS stuff". You know the all the over the top excitment stuff.. .. with the High Fives.. and all that ..crappin wispering stuff.. Its nicer she says for them to not have any talking during the stalk and Instead have it narrated later rather than the raspy crappy whisper talk.. annoying...:rolleyes:
                            Anyway,, ,, I appreciate that you want to hear from folks.. and We can all do that without being rude..
                            It says alot about a man that embraces critiques..
                            Thanks again..
                            Max
                            When you come to a fork in the trail, take it!

                            Rentals for Canoes, Kayaks, Rafts, boats serving the Kenai canoe trail system and the Kenai river for over 15 years. www.alaskacanoetrips.com

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              hey, keep it up. The more alaskan outdoors shows the merrier. There is no place like Alaska, but if shows revealed all the secret spots they wouldn't be much of a secret anymore. I do think you should give a basic area without giving the spot away, but whatever. If it's an entertaining show, thats all that matters.

                              Comment

                              Footer Adsense

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X