Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Gaffs for salmon.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Gaffs for salmon.

    So for my kayak, I have a medium net, a large net, and a buoy and harpoon system. I was thinking about adding either a hand gaff or lip gripper. Lip gripper is good for releasing fish but I don't think they will work for salmon or halibut over 25 pounds. For harvesting, I can see a gaff being effective.

    I always thought gaffs were illegal for salmon anywhere. But all I can find in the regs are:

    "Gaffs prohibited: A gaff may not be used to puncture any fish intended to be released."

    The "gaffs prohibited" seems contrary to the clarification after the colon.

    So if I am keeping it, I can gaff a salmon? Anyone else see anything in regs. Sorry scouring reg books from a smartphone.

    If I am releasing, I don't even want to net it.

  • #2
    I won't speculate about the legal side, but I can speak from the practical side. In my youth I used nothing but a "bat" gaff while working on a commercial salmon troller, always aiming for the head. It worked well there because the fish popped right off when we swung them up onto the deck. The straighter shaft on a wooden "bat" gaff is going to allow the salmon to flip off really easily once you stop your swing, which would be problematic on a kayak. The deeper hook of a traditional halibut gaff would be better for sure. But I have to ask why bother when space is at a premium on a kayak and you're already packing two nets? Heck I'd even do away with the medium net.
    "Lay in the weeds and wait, and when you get your chance to say something, say something good."
    Merle Haggard

    Comment


    • #3
      Good point. Thanks. I don't carry them all with me. The gaff I'd use mainly when going for halibut. Buoy harpoon for anything over 35lbs. A gaff for smaller fish.

      I wish I could say I was a pro at this but I caught my two kings while fishing for halibut as the primary species. I caught my halibut while trolling for kings. Lol.

      A net is the best, but everytime I use a net on a decent fish from a yak. I am out of the water 30 minutes digging out the hooks, dealing with fish, putting the net back, etc. Also a net "grabs" EVERYTHING on the yak.

      So just looking at options. I have to admit directly being attached to any fish over 30 pounds seems a little scary. A net gives and the fish can thrash in the bag without transferring any of the motion to me or the boat. That's not going to be true with a gaff.

      Looking for alternate solutions for different expected catch.

      My last vid, I started in Seward targeting rockfish and halibut so I had my medium net and harpoon. Should have had the larger net but still got it barely to fit. Good thing. I am proficient at grabbing kings to land them if I can get to the gill plates, that would have been very bad. The hooks was under the chin and my trailer was on the gill plate. Would have been no fun to hook my hands and then have the fish take off! Lol. Man overboard!!!!

      Comment


      • #4
        Rudy-
        I used a hand gaff for salmon before I bought my new boat with high sides on it. Now I have to use a net all the time.

        I can confidently say that there is no legal problem hand-gaffing any fish if you are retaining it. A short gaff (the kind with the cross-ways orange handle) will work best, as the shortness of the gaff allows for better control once the gaff is in. You really want to hit it hard and fast, and lift quickly...
        Cliffhanger
        http://www.farnorthpress.com/

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Cliffhanger View Post
          Rudy-
          I used a hand gaff for salmon before I bought my new boat with high sides on it. Now I have to use a net all the time.

          I can confidently say that there is no legal problem hand-gaffing any fish if you are retaining it. A short gaff (the kind with the cross-ways orange handle) will work best, as the shortness of the gaff allows for better control once the gaff is in. You really want to hit it hard and fast, and lift quickly...
          Careful about gaffing "any fish"!!! You cannot gaff ling cod, even if you intend to retain it.

          Comment


          • #6
            Nope. Page 57 of the SC Regs reads: "Lingcod which are gaffed must be retained. A gaff may not be used to puncture any fish intended or required to be released."

            So, no gaffing ANY fish if you are going to release it (no brainer). And you may gaff a lingcod, but you have to keep it.
            Cliffhanger
            http://www.farnorthpress.com/

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Cliffhanger View Post
              Nope. Page 57 of the SC Regs reads: "Lingcod which are gaffed must be retained. A gaff may not be used to puncture any fish intended or required to be released."

              So, no gaffing ANY fish if you are going to release it (no brainer). And you may gaff a lingcod, but you have to keep it.
              I stand corrected. Thanks for the info!

              Comment


              • #8
                Kard.......I thought I saw a bit of hesitation when u landed the last king on video about putting your hand near its mouth after cutting your line. I suggest u get rid of that mesh net u have and get one of the rubber mesh nets available. I just bought one for releasing fish...its nicer for the fish's complextion. The 'rubber' mesh will not tangle on everything in your boat. I hate the line mesh nets in my achilles. As u have found, every time u put it down it tangles. The rubber mesh will not. By the way I also have a short orange handled gaff but have not used it yet.
                Your sarcasm is way, waaaayyyyyyyy more sarcastic than mine! :whistle:
                WWG1WGA! QANON

                Comment


                • #9
                  Show me The Love, Baybee! (and to my rep points please...)

                  ;-{)
                  Cliffhanger
                  http://www.farnorthpress.com/

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I absolutely agree with the use of rubber mesh net ,but they can be a little hard to find for 25-35lb - sized salmon.
                    Cliffhanger
                    http://www.farnorthpress.com/

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Cliffhanger View Post
                      Show me The Love, Baybee! (and to my rep points please...)

                      ;-{)
                      Now, now, no begging!!!!!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        If you are even thinking about releasing the feeders, you can't touch them. They shed waaaaaay too many scales. I don't think a fish could survive it. Am I wrong?

                        The fish was still kicking when I got on shore and took this pic. As "naked" as any salmon I have ever caught.

                        All an evolutionary process. But I am going to pick up a rubber net for my smaller fish like cohos though. I agree with all the stated advantages.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I have used the short handled green floaty gaff before from a kayak in tropical waters. It worked really good. Also if I dropped it, it floated and could be retrieved. Forget who makes them but they are the bright green and blue ones. It does not hurt to have a leash on your gaff as well from a kayak.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            One thing on shorty gaffs and fish as light as salmon- you want them sharper than sharp so it doesn't take a big swing to set them, and with the shaft to the bend polished real smooth. I like a "triangular" point for sharpening. And if they're not smooth the fish doesn't go down to the bend as easily.
                            "Lay in the weeds and wait, and when you get your chance to say something, say something good."
                            Merle Haggard

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              I rarely gaff halibut due to their tendency to flop around and get off/away. I lift the small ones in by the leader, net the medium sized ones, and use a shark hook on a rope for fish over 50#. I woud think a shark hook would work well from a kayak. I have never tried to use the shark hook on a salmon. It might work?

                              Big_E

                              Comment

                              Footer Adsense

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X