Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Late run red fish counts in Kenai is ~500k low

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Late run red fish counts in Kenai is ~500k low

    Noticed the Kenai river is about 500,000 fish low to the last 3 year average , to date.

    50,000 fish per day need to enter the river for the next 10 days to reach the 1.2 million goal.
    Could happen but would be way out of the norm .

    Lots of commercial openings (almost everyday) thru the normal peak run days, July 14th thru the 23rd.

    Sure hope F&G were/are right to let the Drifters at them & the numbers improve.
    Drifters are out again today even with the numbers well below the norm.

    Could also be the sonar count is off.

    Chart shows 2014 daily, then 2014 total (about 500k low) then the totals from 2013, 2012 & 2011 on same day:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	KR 14-12 red cnt.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	127.8 KB
ID:	2513351

    Charts shows 2010 was a lower return year too, & this year is well below 2010
    Different / New sonar since 2010 numbers may be the difference too. ?
    Click image for larger version

Name:	Kenai 14-10 reds.jpg
Views:	2
Size:	73.3 KB
ID:	2513352

    If the numbers aren't reached soon, then what ?

  • #2
    "If the numbers aren't reached soon, then what ?"

    The folks who are waiting for ADFG to raise the daily limit to 6 per day are about to be disappointed.

    Comment


    • #3
      1.2 Million is the UPPER end of the escapement goal. On a run of this projected size, the lower end is 1.0 million, however, if the actual run size is even lower than projected, then the lower end of the goal would be between 750K to 850K. They will get enough escapement. IF, and I mean IF, the sonar numbers are correct.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by BigDipper View Post
        1.2 Million is the UPPER end of the escapement goal. On a run of this projected size, the lower end is 1.0 million, however, if the actual run size is even lower than projected, then the lower end of the goal would be between 750K to 850K. They will get enough escapement. IF, and I mean IF, the sonar numbers are correct.

        Well that's a good way to always have a reachable goal
        if the number is lower, then the goals is lowered Ha Ha

        Past numbers have all been at or just over 1.2 million,
        750 k means 4 years from now, 40% less return ? ?

        Not sure the sonar can tell the difference between reds, pinks & silvers, but
        maybe it can .

        Comment


        • #5
          I believe the inriver goal is 1-1.2 million for a run this size, and ADFG is still fairly confident they will achieve that. That means plenty of fish for the inriver users, and hopefully a spawning escapement inside the MSY goalposts. We've had very healthy escapements the last few years - I wouldn't worry about a spawning escapement inside the SEG goal range from a future yield standpoint. In fact, it may be more productive when stacked up against the last few escapements at or over the top of the SEG goal.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by mudbuddy View Post
            Well that's a good way to always have a reachable goal
            if the number is lower, then the goals is lowered Ha Ha

            Past numbers have all been at or just over 1.2 million,
            750 k means 4 years from now, 40% less return ? ?

            Not sure the sonar can tell the difference between reds, pinks & silvers, but
            maybe it can .
            Nope it can't tell the difference. ADF&G, the commercial guys, and the setnetters will tell you it can but logic reveals the truth. What we should be worried about is how to increase the overall size of the pie instead of how to divide up the current sized pie. Eventually this fishery will be destroyed just like the Atlantic salmon fishery.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Yellowstone View Post
              Nope it can't tell the difference. ADF&G, the commercial guys, and the setnetters will tell you it can but logic reveals the truth. What we should be worried about is how to increase the overall size of the pie instead of how to divide up the current sized pie. Eventually this fishery will be destroyed just like the Atlantic salmon fishery.

              Lots of misinformation here for some reason. The goals are in-river goals not spawning goals. They include harvest above the sonar. The last three years the goals have been exceeded and that actually can reduce further yields on average. You cannot say only half the goal was made so only half as many fish will come back. The production curves do not work that way. Look up Ricker curve on google to get any idea of this.

              Relative to species and counting reds, pinks, and coho. Lots of information on this on this forum in the past and from ADF&G. Fishwhees are used to apportion the counts. In some systems the fishwheel catches are adjusted to account for gear selectivity but in the Kenai that is not needed.

              Relative to the goals for this year ADF&G is probably shooting for 1 million in-river and it is not at of the norm to achieve that in August since the fishing power is so limited without the set nets. They are on track to meet the goals for Kenai but even at the present level of escapement the system can produce millions of fish for the future.

              Comment


              • #8
                Although I agree this year was not a record breaker, if you compare it to the long term average, this year is about 20K behind the 30 year average. As of Monday the cumulative count was up to 73K. The 30 year average cumulative count for the 28th of July is right around 90K. And the 30 year average cumulative count for the whole month of the July is just over 100K. If the daily counts make it over 33K every day until the 31st, then it will be in line with the 30 year average. Not a great year on the Kenai for sure. But at least the silver lining is fish creek was awesome and produced lots of fish for those looking for a few more fish to fill the freezer. I personally am not alarmed by the low numbers of the Kenai just yet. Now, if the numbers look like this year after year for several years to come, then I think we need to be concerned. Just my two cents.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I think the Kenai fish were there, they just got gobbled up in Cook Inlet before they could reach the river.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by AaronP View Post
                    I think the Kenai fish were there, they just got gobbled up in Cook Inlet before they could reach the river.
                    Not sure what you mean...The in-river escapement goals have already been met, and then some. Most dipnetters who put in the effort already got all their fish. That's the way it's supposed to happen...all the different users get fish and the River meets escapement. No question the run wasn't banner and estimates were off, but that's fishing.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Funstastic View Post
                      Not sure what you mean...The in-river escapement goals have already been met, and then some. Most dipnetters who put in the effort already got all their fish. That's the way it's supposed to happen...all the different users get fish and the River meets escapement. No question the run wasn't banner and estimates were off, but that's fishing.
                      Bingo :topjob:
                      Your bait stinks and your boat is ugly

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by AaronP View Post
                        I think the Kenai fish were there, they just got gobbled up in Cook Inlet before they could reach the river.
                        There were and are plenty being caught on the river by anyone who actually tries and enjoys fishing enough to put forth the effort to be successful.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by smithtb View Post
                          There were and are plenty being caught on the river by anyone who actually tries and enjoys fishing enough to put forth the effort to be successful.
                          Oh I got plenty for myself. What about the low numbers returning to the Russian?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by AaronP View Post
                            Oh I got plenty for myself. What about the low numbers returning to the Russian?
                            Well, sounds like some of them are in your freezer, but the season isn't over yet...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Bushwhack Jack View Post
                              Although I agree this year was not a record breaker, if you compare it to the long term average, this year is about 20K behind the 30 year average. As of Monday the cumulative count was up to 73K. The 30 year average cumulative count for the 28th of July is right around 90K. And the 30 year average cumulative count for the whole month of the July is just over 100K. If the daily counts make it over 33K every day until the 31st, then it will be in line with the 30 year average. Not a great year on the Kenai for sure. But at least the silver lining is fish creek was awesome and produced lots of fish for those looking for a few more fish to fill the freezer. I personally am not alarmed by the low numbers of the Kenai just yet. Now, if the numbers look like this year after year for several years to come, then I think we need to be concerned. Just my two cents.
                              You cannot look at averages since in most years the Kenai goal is exceeded. Also, the goals vary by run strength. If you want to see how production is measured look at the brood tables for Kenai which are available from ADF&G on request.

                              Comment

                              Footer Adsense

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X