hummingbird or garmin? any advise?

[POLE BENDER]

Got all the good stuff figured out on my big boat, but am looking for a depth/fish finder for my open skiff.
Skiff is an open Klamth, that we use in rivers, lakes, and to do a little trolling with in the inlet.
I am undecided on a cheap finder for this boat. transducer will be mounted on a liftable flat bar on the back of the transom, as the boat is beached a lot.
obviously needs to be waterproof (most are)
I have been looking at the garmin echo 200 and the hummingbird piranhamax176, anyone that has one and might be willing to share there thoughs?

thanks
polebender

[Jimw]

Garmin 160C I run this unit its worth looking at

[ADUKHNT]

Garmin without a second thought.

[POLE BENDER]

thanks guys, was leaning that way but thought i would about the HB anyway.
cheers