OK with all the hullabuloo going on over at the Most accurate factory rifle thread I just thought I would post this question in a new thread to keep from hijacking that one.
So this is all completely theoretical but lets go into imaginary land for a bit and see what you all think.
You are an avid hunter and handloader, as many of us are and you have only one big game rifle at your disposal(remember this is imaginary land). You have a big hunt booked that you have spent alot of hard earned dough on. You have been busy loading ammo and dialing in your only rifle, lets say just for fun that it happens to be chambered for the 300 Winchester magnum. You have tried every concievable combination of bullet and powder as well as factory ammo, and the only load that will shoot to the magical MOA mark happens to launch a Sierra Matchking. All of the other loads shoot around 1.75 to 2.25in groups at 100yds. There is not enough time to drop it off at the gunsmiths place, and you have a decision to make.
So do you use the magic MOA load with its very lightly constucted bullet or do you choose a less accurate load shooting something like a Nosler Partition?
I know what load I would take so lets here what all yoou accuracy fanatics have to say.