I discovered the pattern on Friday. Had 3 fisher people on board and two down riggers.
Downrigger #1 with doger and fly caught fish at 43 feet down
Downrigger #2 with K2 plug caught fish at 50 feet down
Flat line with sinker and Herring bouncing along the bottom caught fish

Its like Buck Perry, the famous bass fisherman of another era used to say, "The fish are in the shallows, or in the deep water, or somewhere in between!"

Follow this pattern and success is guaranteed