Choosing A Small Kicker
I'm kinda in the market for a small outboard around 9-10hp for use on a 10' skiff, but at a loss as to what to look for. Would you go for one of the 4-cycles, or stick with standard 2-cycle? Is there much weight difference? Do you think that 10hp would be enough to get a 10' aluminum skiff up on step with two guys on board? (both about 180-200lb) Recommendations?
Use the search button
The engine is one of the most necessary parts of your boat. Without it, you are not going to go very far. Outboard motors are the most common type of propulsion used on boats today. This motor is mounted to the stern end of the boat, with an attached propeller in the water. There are many choices and considerations that you need to make when it comes to purchasing an outboard motor for your boat. The type or power of the engine you get depends on the size of your boat, the speed you want, and what the boat will be used for.
Types of Outboard Motors:
The two types of outboard motors available are 2-Stroke and 4-Stroke engines. There are positives and negatives to each of these engine types. Because of the light weight, 2-Stroke engines are chosen when good top end speed and acceleration is needed. 4-Stroke engines run smoother and more economical, and are usually chosen for use on lakes and rivers.
2-Stroke Outboard Motors:
2-Stroke engines are lighter and faster, allowing for more top end speed and acceleration. They are also more affordable and have a higher resale value. Because 2-Stroke engines have been around for almost 80 years; necessary parts are more readily available, making repair easier. The design on these engines is less complex than that of a 4 stroke engine, which allows for fewer problems to arise.
There are also some cons to buying a 2-Stroke engine. These engines are not as environmentally friendly, and produce more pollution and smoke. In the non oil injection models; is necessary to mix gas with oil. These engines are noisier, have a rougher idle, and are sometimes difficult to start. There are also some problems with spark plugs fouling.
Boaters who would be most likely to choose a 2-Stroke outboard engine if they are interested in speed, performance, and acceleration. This may be the engine of choice if you own a smaller boat that may not be able to hold the weight of a 4-Stroke engine. A 2-Stroke engine is also suitable if you are more familiar with engine repairs, or even want a motor that is easy to repair and can be brought anywhere to be fixed. If you are not required to operate in a body of water that is for four stroke engines only, you may want to purchase a 2-Stroke. If you would like the most power for weight of the engine, or interested in more speed, acceleration, and performance; a 2-Stroke engine is for you.
4-Stroke Outboard Motors:
4-Stroke engines run quieter and idle smoother, allowing for a more pleasurable ride. They are safer for the economy with less pollution and smoke, and are better on fuel. They are accepted on all bodies of water. These engines are also very reliable.
The negative aspects of a 4 stroke engine are that they are more complex, which allows for more problems to arise. When repair is needed; it is more expensive, hard to find trained mechanics, and limited parts on the market. 4-Stroke engines are also less powerful 2-Stroke engines. Because they weigh more than 2-Stroke engines, they may be too heavy for some smaller boats.
You are most likely to use a 4 stroke engine if you are interested in trolling along on a quiet, smooth ride. These engines are better for use on bigger boats. If the water in your area requires a ď4-Stroke only" boat, it is probably a good idea to go with this engine. If you would rather give up engine speed and acceleration for a cleaner engine, you may want to purchase a 4-Stroke. Also, if you are interested in less pollution and smoke, and donít want to have to mix oil; a 4-Stroke engine is for you.
2-Stroke: Evinrude, Yamaha, Nissan and Mercury.
4-Stroke: Johnson, Honda, Mercury, Nissan, Suzuki, Tohatsu and Yamaha.
Both 2 and 4-Stroke engines have advantages and disadvantages. You need to decide how you are going to use your motor, and what you want it to do for you. Because 4-Stroke engines are newer, they are continually improving to make purchase and repair easier on the boater.
A 10' skiff and two guys is small. With that said I've got a 12' Klamath and an 8hp Mariner two stroke that easily planes out with two adults.
What ever you do, 2 stroke or 4 stroke, get a model that is a two cylinder. It is much smoother and more relaxing to spend the day next to.
I agree! The one cylinder four stroke motors are real shakers. I don't even like holding the tiller handle on them. I would much rather have a twin 2 stroke 6 hp than I would a single 5 hp Honda any day of the week and I like Hondas. But to answer the original poster, the 2 stroke is way lighter in a 10hp model if that is a consideration and in this 10 hp size they both should be twins. I doubt you are going to see a noticable diffference in fuel efficiency, but there sure is in price. Just my 2 cents.....
Originally Posted by Sobie2
I have a 8hp Yamaha 2 stroke and a 10' Zodiak zoom easily get on step with 2 adults.
Will get on step with 2 adults and on teen but you have to shift weight to do so.
May sell in the spring.