It's not that easy comparing the three because it's not a direct comparison. For most people, Homer's claim to fame is halibut. Most of the charters are 6-packs or larger and they target halibut. There are halibut to be caught in Sitka and Seward too, but in Sitka this coming year, barring the court's overturning it, there will be a 1 halibut limit.

Seward is also primarily 6-packs or larger and there is more of a mix of salmon and halibut, especially silvers. Sitka charters are primarily 4 people on a boat. They have great ocean fishing for Kings and silvers. I have also had great halibut fishing there. The "running time" vs the "fishing time" in Sitka tends to be a little bit better for "combination" charters because the salmon and halibut fishing seem to be closer together and usually, not always, closer to port.

No matter where you go the results will vary more on the quality of your charter/guide and the weather than on the port. Hope this helps.


mcdermott cues poison cues predator cues